Index Life Insurance vs 401(k): Which Is Best For You?

Find me

The decision of how you want to manage the funds you’re putting aside for retirement has far-reaching effects as it determines when you’ll be able to access these funds. In this Index Life Insurance vs 401(K) comparison, we’re going to help you decide which of these options is better suited to your needs.

Either of these plans can be obtained through major insurance companies like State Farm, GEICO, or Liberty Mutual, although under different conditions. In addition, the majority of companies in the United States provide their employees with the 401(k) plan and cover a fraction of the monthly rates.

So, chances are that you already have a 401(k) or a similar policy if you’re fully employed, and if this is the case, then the question is whether or not you need the Index Life Insurance policy.

Our Index Life Insurance vs 401(k) comparison will help you answer this question and provide you with the information you need to understand how these policies are different.

Also, you should go through our Life Insurance Portability vs Conversion comparison if you want to find out more about these life insurance policies.

The Main Differences Between the Index Life Insurance vs 401(k)

The Main Differences Between the Index Life Insurance and 401(k) are:

  • Index Life Insurance is a form of life insurance policy, whereas the 401(k) is a form of retirement plan
  • 401(k) funds transferred to the beneficiaries are taxed, whereas after the Index Life Insurance policyholder passes away, the beneficiary receives the tax-free death benefit
  • Index Life Insurance policyholder covers the entire rate, whereas the rates of the 401(k) policy can be split between the employer and the policyholder
  • 401(k) policy prevents the policyholders from withdrawing funds before they turn 59.5 years, whereas the funds invested in the Index Life Policy are available at all times
  • Index Life Insurance policy allows you to withdraw funds without covering the taxes, whereas the funds deposited through 401(k) plan are taxed upon withdrawal

Examining the Key Features of Index Life Insurance and 401(k)

life insurance

Index Life Insurance

A brief research of the life insurance policies most insurance companies offer will reveal some differences between policies. Whole life insurance, Universal life insurance, and term life insurance are the three most common types of life insurance policies.

Index Life Insurance is a form of universal life insurance policy that includes a cash-value account. These policies are fully customizable as you can determine the maximum values of the death benefit and premiums.

In case the value of the funds in your cash account increases, you can utilize the profits to cover the cost of the premium. In addition, the interest rate of Index Life Insurance policies isn’t fixed; instead, it depends on the performance of a market index such as Nasdaq, Dow Jones, or S&P 500.

Read our Survivor Benefit Plan vs Life Insurance comparison if you’re not sure which policy you should choose.

Key features

  • Suitable for investors in their 40s and 50s
  • Beneficiaries are usually entitled to considerable death benefit payouts
  • Interest rates are tied to the performance of a specific market index
  • There are no restrictions on when you can withdraw your funds
  • Protects savings from market crashes
  • Policyholders can borrow against the cash value
  • Numerous tax advantages
  • Allows policyholders to make cumulative contributions

What does Index Life Insurance entail?

Unlike the Term Life Insurance that covers the policyholder for a set period usually between 10 and 30 years, the Index Life Insurance doesn’t expire until the beneficiaries receive the death benefit. Failing to pay premiums may cause the policy to lapse, and if this happens, all funds in the account will be taxed.

However, these Life Policies allow you to make cumulative contributions, which enables you to balance your investments by over-funding one year to cover for the previous year in which you under-funded.

These policies contain cash value account and death benefit components, and all the profits you make from the market index end up in your cash-value account.

Keep in mind that most companies limit the maximum return you make, and they guarantee that you won’t lose money if the market index starts dropping. The money you withdraw from a cash value account is tax-free and is available to you at any moment.

Read our Ladder Life Insurance review if you’re interested in term life insurance policies.

Fund management

The particulars of an Index Life Insurance policy depend on the insurer, but in most cases, you’ll be able to decide how much of your funds you want to tie to the market index, and the rest will have a fixed interest rate.

The profits you make will be available to you at all times, and you won’t have to pay income taxes for the sums you withdraw. In addition, you can take out loans from the Index Life Insurance, but the size of a loan depends on the sum you have in the cash value account and the terms of your policy.

You won’t have to go through the credit check, pay taxes for the money you borrow, or cover any penalties. Besides, you’ll be under no obligation to return the sum you borrowed. It is also worth adding that the policy insurer doesn’t limit the total amount of contributions you can make in a year.

Go through this Liberty Mutual vs GEICO comparison to find out which company issues better life insurance policies.

Other noteworthy features

The amount of money you can earn on index market interest rates has a cap, so if the stocks you’ve invested in are performing well, you’ll earn only a fraction of what you could earn if you bought stocks on the stock exchange.

Even so, investing in an Index Life Insurance guarantees that you’re not going to lose money if the value of stocks drops. It is also important to understand the concept of leverage if you want to maximize the profits you’re making through this policy.

Leverage enables you to borrow money and invest it in hopes that the returns will be higher than the sum you borrowed.

Bear in mind, that this policy doesn’t protect you entirely from the losses that occur in the event of negative leverage, but you won’t be pressed to pay back the loan within a set frame of time.

Read our guide to finding the best life insurance if you need more information about the features your policy should have.


Despite having some obvious advantages, the Index Life Insurance isn’t suited for everyone. Generally, people in their 20s are better off setting up a retirement fund since their lives aren’t in immediate danger. High monthly rates and fees are also something you’ll have to consider if you’re thinking about getting a universal life insurance policy because these policies are usually significantly more expensive than the available alternatives.

Even though it is possible to increase and decrease the contributions you make on an annual level, failing to meet the minimum premium will result in the lapse or surrender of the policy.

Consulting with a financial advisor before opting to purchase an Index Life Insurance policy is recommended, as it will enable you to get better acquainted with all the risks and advantages associated with these types of life insurance policies.

Go through our Liberty Mutual vs Esurance comparison for more information about the benefits of purchasing life insurance from one of these companies.

401(k) Insurance


Although they essentially serve the same purpose, life insurance policies and retirement plans have several key differences. Retirement plans don’t include a death benefit, while you may have to pay for penalties if you want to tap into your savings before you reach a certain age.

Even so, policyholders can assign a beneficiary who will receive the funds from the 401(k) account if they die before retirement. The 401(k) is just one among numerous types of retirement plans, as you can also choose a 403 (b), IRA, or HSA plan to mention a few.

Most employers in the United States offer 401(k) to their employees, but the specifics of the plan depend on the employer and your preferences.

The IRS limits the maximum amount you can put into a 401(k) account per year, so you won’t be able to set aside more money than the law permits. Read our Allstate vs Liberty Mutual comparison to find out which company offers better retirement plans.

Key features

  • Affordable monthly rates
  • Policyholders don’t have to cover the entire premium by themselves
  • 401(k) plan is available through employers
  • Suitable for young people who don’t lead high-risk lifestyles
  • All contributions are tax-deferred
  • People older than 50 can make catch-up contributions
  • Owners of 401(k) can choose from several investment options
  • 10% tax penalty for all money withdrawals made before the age of 60

What does 401(k) entail?

Even though 401(k) plans are customized to each policyholder, they usually have the same properties. An employer commonly supplies these retirement plans, and you won’t be able to get them as a private citizen unless you’re self-employed.

Since the majority of the 401(k) plans are provided by companies, employees can choose to redirect a portion of their paycheck into contributions for this account. In many cases, employers contribute a certain percentage of their staff’s yearly salary to 401(k) accounts.

The IRS defines 401(k) as the ‘defined contribution plan’ because the policyholder agrees to make regular contributions to their retirement account. You can choose between traditional and Roth 401(k) depending on how you want your savings to be taxed.

You won’t be able to access your money before you retire, even if you need to make a hardship withdrawal without paying the income tax for the amount you’d like to withdraw. Go through our guide to finding the best medical insurance if you’re exploring health insurance policy options.

Fund management

The contributions you make to a 401(k) account are tax-deferred, which means they aren’t taxed before they reach the account. The idea behind it is that a policyholder is going to fall into a lower tax bracket after retirement and consequently pay less tax for the funds they accumulated in their account.

You will have to pay tax every time you withdraw money from your retirement account before you reach the age specified by the insurance company. However, you can borrow up to 50% of the sum you have in your 401(k) account, although you can’t take more than $50.000 within a 12-month period.

Investing through a 401(k) account is possible, but the administrator of the account usually selects the investment options and offers them to the owner of the account.

It is worth pointing out that investing in bonds or stock through a 401(k) account is unusual, and you should choose the Index Life Insurance policy if you want to use your funds to buy or sell stocks.

Other noteworthy features

Even though companies offer 401(k) plans, employees aren’t automatically enrolled in the program. Hence, you must make a request through the company’s HR department to join this retirement plan and start making monthly contributions.

The return of the investments you make through this account isn’t limited, so if your investment performs well, you will receive all the profits and not just a percentage like with the Index Life Insurance policies.

You will have four options at your disposal if you decide to change your employer after setting up a 401(k) account. Moving the funds to an IRA account, keeping the account tied to the previous company, or transferring the funds to a 401(k) account associated with the new employer are your best options.

Even though you can opt to withdraw the funds from the 401(k) account after terminating the contract with your previous employer, you will have to pay the income tax for the entire sum you withdraw.


The money you keep in your 401(k) retirement account is protected against market volatility as long as it is not invested, but if you invested your money and the market crashes, you could end up losing a sizable portion of your life savings.

Despite this risk, the 401(k) plan is still one of the most reliable retirement plans in the United States, that is utilized by a large number of companies. Most financial experts recommend this type of savings account to young professionals as it enables them to avoid the high fees of life insurance plans.

Currently, the maximum annual contribution you can make to a 401(k) plan is limited by the IRS to $19.500, but this amount may increase in time.

Owners of these accounts are required to start taking minimum distributions once they turn 72 unless they’re still employed by the same employer that enabled them to open the account.

Index Life Insurance vs 401(K) – Pros and cons

medical insurance

Index Life Insurance


  • Vast investment possibilities
  • Funds are available at all times and free of tax
  • Beneficiaries receive a huge death benefit
  • The amount policyholders can contribute to the account on a yearly level isn’t limited


  • Insurance companies limit investment returns to few percentages
  • High monthly rates

401(K) Insurance


  • Available through most employers in the United States
  • Contributions can be deducted from the salary
  • Unlimited returns on investment
  • 401(k) plan owners can borrow up to $50.000 per year from their account


  • The maximum annual contribution is limited to $19.500
  • Investments made through the 401(k) are not protected if the market crashes

The Best Alternatives to the Index Life Insurance vs 401(k)

medical insurance

All insurance companies offer a broad spectrum of life insurance policies and retirement plans. Hence, your options aren’t limited to just Index Life Insurance or different versions of the 401(k) plan.

Each retirement solution has its advantages and it approaches tax differently, which is why it is important to get better acquainted with the terms of a policy or a plan before opting for it.

We’ve selected some of the best alternatives to the Index Life Insurance and 401(k), so let’s take a look at what they have to offer.

Term Life Insurance

Instead of opting for a universal or whole life insurance policy, you can choose a Term Life Insurance policy if you want to limit its duration.

If you select the level term policy, the death benefit will remain the same until the policy expires, while the death benefit is going to shrink progressively if you pick the decreasing term insurance policy.


The Individual Retirement Account or IRA is available to anyone who generates a monthly income. However, some providers require a minimum before allowing you to open this type of savings account.

The maximum annual contribution to IRA is limited to just $6,000 or $7,000 for individuals older than 50. There are different types of IRA accounts to choose from, which enables you to pick the option that best fits your retirement plans.


Although it’s not a conventional retirement plan, the HSA or Health Savings Accounts are aimed at people who want to save money for potential medical expenses they might have to cover after they retire.

The maximum yearly contribution to this type of account is set to $3,600 for individuals or $7,200 with Family Coverage. All withdrawals from this account are tax-free if they are used to cover the costs of medical treatment.

Frequently asked questions about Index Life Insurance and 401(k)

FAQ about Life Index Insurance and 401(k)

Question: Do I have to pay tax for the gains I make through Index Life Insurance investments?

Answer: No, all the profits you make by investing through Index Life Insurance are tax-free, but the insurer might limit the maximum return on investment to several percent.

Question: What happens with my Index Life Insurance if the market plummets?

Answer: Insurance companies offer the principle guarantee that protects your investments from losses, so you won’t lose money if the market plummets.

Question: Can I overfund the 401(k) plan?

Answer: Yes, you can. However, the sum that exceeds the annual contribution limit of $19.500 will be taxed at 6% and returned to you.

Question: Is it possible to make catch-up contributions to a 401(k) account?

Answer: Yes, it is, but not before you turn 50. After that point, you’ll be able to contribute an additional $6.500 to your 401(k) account every year.

Our Verdict: What is a better solution for retirement Index Life Insurance or 401(k)?

We all want to accumulate enough wealth to live comfortably after we retire. 401(k) and Index Life insurance let you work towards this goal, although in different ways. Instead of deciding on one or the other, you should consider an Index Life Insurance as a supplement to your 401(k) retirement plan.

Chances are that you can get the 401(k) account through your employer and set aside a certain amount for your retirement every month. Getting the Index Life Insurance policy will extend your investment options and enable you to leave a sizable death benefit to the beneficiaries you choose.

Was this Index Life Insurance vs 401(k) comparison useful? Let us know in the comments or continue reading our guide to finding the best home insurance.


Recommended Reads:

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top